If you are looking for the best pair of ice fishing mittens, you might find there are many different options.
When I decided to look for a new pair of mittens for ice fishing this season, I decided to buy a few different pairs to be used in different scenarios. This included a cheap pair to keep in the truck to my heated pair to keep my fingers heated on extremely cold ice fishing days.
In this article, I will go through my top selections including the pairs of ice fishing mittens I decided to buy.
What Are the Best Ice Fishing Mittens?
The best ice fishing mittens can be warmer than a pair of gloves since your fingers are kept together to keep each other warm. Ice fishing mittens can also be more convenient when baiting a hook or untangling a line as the finger portion of the ice fishing mittens flip back to expose fingerless gloves.
Below is a summary of the five best ice fishing mittens, then I dive into each option a little bit more.
- Click the View Product to see current pricing and options.
- Click the Read More to jump to our review of the product.
*Special Note – This article contains affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission to support my writing if you click a link and purchase anything at no extra cost to you. Thank you in advance for your support of my passion. Cheers!
Best Ice Fishing Mittens
Overall Best Ice Fishing Mittens
Best Heated Ice Fishing Mittens
Best Leather Ice Fishing Mittens
Best Cheap Ice Fishing Mittens
Best Cheap Extreme Cold Weather Ice Fishing Mittens
Best Ice Fishing Mittens Review
The overall best ice fishing mittens are slightly thicker than gloves and they have some more comfort and protection from the cold. The palmyth ice fishing mittens are some of the most unique on the market today. They are made from durable Cordura Nylon to make them rugged.
These gloves have removable fingertips, which means you don’t have to struggle with a mobile device. However, it has a touchscreen-sensitive design. These gloves are designed to be used as mittens when you are not busy and the mittens are perfect for cold weather. The 3M Thinsulate will ensure that you have cold weather protection.
- 3M Thinsulate lining
- Removable fingertips and mitten
- Touchscreen compatible
- Durable and rugged design
- Expensive price tag
Once again, having heated mittens will ensure that you can control the different temperatures. The best heated ice fishing mittens are the heated gloves, men’s women’s heated ski gloves mittens, which feature a 7.4-volt battery. One can use the battery to power the gloves and they have various heating elements to change the temperatures.
The gloves are made from sheep leather. However, the sheep leather has been treated to ensure they remain soft. The insulation materials are ideal for keeping you warm once the battery dies down. You will also have a warranty to ensure that the gloves work and to make sure they give you all the protection you might need.
- Heated elements
- Ergonomic design
- Durable sheep leather
- Battery is not reliable
Leather is one of the most durable materials on the market today. While it might not be heated when you are using it, the insulation on the inside of the Palmyth magnetic leather ice fishing gloves will allow them to stay warm. We have selected them as the best leather ice fishing mittens.
These gloves can be used for various purposes. The main fingers have been designed to be in the form of mittens. Additionally, the thumb and index fingers have been cut, which means that you can use them for operating your mobile devices. These mittens are highly regarded for the value they offer in cold weather.
- Heavily insulated
- Made from durable leather
- Cut-off thumb and index finger
- Magnetic enclosure
- Not ideal for long fingers
The Carhartt waterproof insulated mitt is one of the most basic mittens you would often find. It is the best cheap ice fishing mittens, which has been constructed from polyester. The polyester might not compare with the leather. However, it is one of the top options when you want a waterproof mitten.
The mittens are pretty basic, but they have a useful design for those that want to use them in cold weather conditions. They have a strap enclosure that will keep them tight and your hands secure. Much like the others, these gloves are heavily insulated. FastDry Technology is implemented to keep the gloves dry at all times.
- FastDry Technology
- Wicks away moisture
- Strap enclosure
- Not waterproof
The waterproof ice fishing mittens are some of the basic options on the market today and they are similar to the previous mittens. They are considered the best cheap extreme cold weather ice fishing mittens, which feature a polyester and nylon blend construction but are waterproof in all conditions.
These gloves have Thinsulate for the insulation, which means they can keep one protected in the coldest of weather conditions. While they will keep your hands cold, the downside is that the gloves do not have any use for mobile devices. One will need to remove them if you are to set up the ice fishing equipment or use your mobile conditions.
- 3M Thinsulate
- Blended and durable construction
- Very affordable
- Basic design
- Not for setting up equipment
- Not for mobile devices